The NEW #SmallWins by Art Storefronts!

Do captions on Reels actually make a noticeable difference?

I finally started posting short Reels of my travel sketches, little clips of a watercolor coming together at a café table or a quick pan across a finished piece. I've been going back and forth on whether to add captions to every single one.

Part of me thinks the visual should speak for itself, but I also know a lot of people scroll with sound off. For those of you who've been consistent with adding text captions to your Reels, did you notice a real difference in reach or engagement compared to when you skipped them? And do you keep them minimal, like just a line or two, or do you narrate the whole process?

Still figuring out what works for this kind of content so I'd love to hear what you've seen on your end.

6

5 Comments

Sort by:
Arty at ArtHelperjust now

Hey! Your instinct about sound-off scrolling is right on the money, and the fact that you're already posting café table watercolor clips means you have the hard part down.

Short answer: yes, captions make a measurable difference. Here's why and how to keep them from feeling like a chore.

- Roughly 80% of Instagram users scroll with sound off. Without captions, your Reel is a silent movie with no title cards. The algorithm tracks watch time, and captions give people a reason to stay through the whole clip instead of swiping past at second two.

- For travel sketches specifically, a two or three word location tag plus one line about what you're painting ("Florence rooftop, first wash") adds context that makes viewers feel like they're AT the café table with you. That emotional hook is what turns a scroll-past into a save or a share.

- Keep them tight. Two to four short lines timed to the action on screen. Not a paragraph dump. The caption should pace with the brush, not compete with it.

- Use CapCut (free) to drop captions in. Takes about five minutes once you get the flow down, and you can pick a clean font that matches your aesthetic so the text feels intentional, not slapped on.

The visual absolutely does heavy lifting on its own, but captions are the difference between someone watching three seconds and someone watching the whole thing and then tapping your profile. Worth the five extra minutes.

Want help writing a batch of short, punchy captions for your travel sketch Reels? I can draft a set for you based on your work.

Other resources you might find helpful:

- What Arty Said! - May 22, 2026 11:19 AM — Social strategy for selling art through storytelling and video content, with user examples of what worked beyond captions alone.

Arty is our artist super-assistant. Trained on all things related to art business & marketing. use @arty in a post or comment to ask Arty directly. upvote & downvote to provide feedback.

0
Linnie Aikens1h ago

Congratulations on doing your first reels! I totally agree with Gin and Arlene. That's where you build the story, where people connect and engage, and I too, never browse with the sound on, so captions are important.

0

Captions absolutely help. Many people browse on trains, in the gym, at work, in a waiting room where they don't have headphones or sound. Captions help capture the views of those people.

0
Arlene Gottlieb2h ago

Most of what I've noticed, scrolling through my own feed, is that I almost never have sound on. Lying in bed, sitting in a café, on the tram. I imagine most people are the same. When I started adding a line or two of text to my own short videos, even simple things like a pan across a weathered façade, I could tell more people stayed with it. They didn't have to guess what they were watching or wonder if they were missing something. I'd say keep them on every clip. Doesn't need to be a full narration, just enough so the piece isn't silent and mysterious in the wrong way. Let the visual breathe, but give viewers something to hold onto.

0

I think it's worth adding something, it's just another thing to catch the readers eye and gives them a brief description of what it is your showing. Maybe try alternating and see the comparisons?

0