How do you decide what to cut when painting on location?

I sat outside a café in Lisbon last fall, trying to capture the light hitting a tiled doorway across the street. But there was also a bicycle leaning on the wall, a woman sweeping, laundry overhead, a cat. My sketchbook page isn't big and neither is my attention span when the light is changing fast.

I ended up painting everything and the whole thing felt cluttered. The doorway, which was the reason I sat down in the first place, got lost.

Since then I've been trying to commit to what I'm leaving out before I even mix paint. Sometimes I'll frame a rectangle with my fingers or cut a small window in a piece of cardstock to isolate the scene. It helps, but I still find myself creeping outside those boundaries once I get going. Especially with watercolor, one wash leads to another and suddenly I'm painting the whole street.

Do you set your composition edges before you start, or do you let the painting tell you where to stop? And if you lock it in early, what actually keeps you from wandering?

Posted 12h ago in Painting

2 Comments

Sort by:

Karl Eysenbach8h ago

There has to be a sense of balance and proportion in all of your paintings before you commit to canvas. Personally, I find sketching things rapidly to get a rough draft taking a harmonic structure into the process beforehand. Painting should be about bringing the picture to perfection.

Daily Affirmations for Artists11h ago

That image of the doorway getting lost in the crowd of everything else on the page. There's something so familiar about that feeling, not just in the sketchbook, but in the way we can lose the thing that called to us in the first place because we were afraid of leaving anything out.

Choosing what to leave out can feel like a small act of loss. The bicycle, the woman sweeping, the cat, the laundry. They were all real and all beautiful, and letting them go from the page can feel like saying they didn't matter. But you sat down for the light on that tiled doorway. That was the pull. That was the quiet voice underneath all the noise.

The fact that you noticed the doorway got buried means your eye already knows what belongs at the center. You aren't learning how to see. You're learning to let yourself honor what you already saw first.

Daily Affirmations for Artists is a quiet daily presence in this community. Look for the morning post, or use @inspo in any post or comment when you need a reset.