General

Is the fat-over-lean rule actually necessary for oil painters?

Some of us were taught that fat-over-lean is gospel—lean layers first, progressively oilier on top, or your painting will crack in twenty years. Others paint alla prima straight from the tube, or fat-over-fat through every layer, and their work holds up just fine. I go back and forth on this myself: I respect the old-master logic, but I also know plenty of painters who ignore it completely and never see a crack.

(The comment badges will show your vote… choose wisely 😈)

Tap an option to voteEnds in 5 days
Posted in General
7

8 Comments

Sort by:
Azrial1d ago

I do what I want, art is meant to free us, I have no rules and follow none. I am self taught and pay more attention to the history of old masters and how they started, what they used and have come to find that the oldest masters painted with feel, experimented and found what fit for them and the material they painted on so the rules change depending on what material is being painted. I paint on wood and so I adjust what I use to make the painting live. It is the one place where there are no rules.

1
Siegmund SchneiderVoted: Essential—flexible over brittle prevents cracking15h ago
Translated from Deutsch

Absolutely right, if the work is to last longer.

0
Jon BandishVoted: Essential—flexible over brittle prevents cracking23h ago

It is essential, at the very least for your education on what mediums will, what you can do with paint, what each type of brush can do, etc. it’s also essential for anyone interested in realism. I would argue that most “painters” today have very little understanding of these more traditional aspects and rules of painting and lack the education behind it. I guess I’m a grumpy old man nowadays 😂

0
SasciaVoted: Essential—flexible over brittle prevents cracking23h ago
Translated from Deutsch

I paint with water-soluble oil paints. But I adhere to the rule. I use a thicker painting medium with every further layer. ( I can mix the medium with water. Then I mix more medium and less water with the next layer) this is how I follow the rule "Fat over Lean" Greetings from Switzerland, Sascia

0
Dana VolungisVoted: Essential—flexible over brittle prevents cracking1d ago

The reasoning behind the theory is that thin layers will dry quickly, fat or thick layers take much longer. Sometimes a fat layer will take a year to completely dry. The cracking happens when under layers of thick paint finally dry and contract pulling the thin dry layers on top apart, thus the cracking. That’s why the old traditional ways start with brown tone painting, or thin underpainting and build up layers slowly.

0
lproteviVoted: Only matters if you use mediums or solvents heavily2d ago

A craquellature is sometimes a welcome texture in an oil painting ....if you are going to experiment with surfaces !

0
lproteviVoted: Only matters if you use mediums or solvents heavily2d ago

Sometimes a slight craquell

0
Valerie PantaloneVoted: Essential—flexible over brittle prevents cracking2d ago

This is true; over time, the paint will crack and break away from the canvas. I have an oil painting from my baby artist days, and I unintentionally did this. Over time, there was a weird chemical reaction, and the paint fell off. Most people don't know that with acrylic, you can lean over fat and won't have a problem. Creates nice effects, too.

0